Western Cape – A motorcyclist has lost a R4.7 million claim against the Road Accident Fund (RAF) after the Western Cape High Court found that he had failed to prove that another driver was negligent in a 2021 collision.
In a judgment delivered on 16 November 2026, Acting Judge Siviwe Yake dismissed Desire Bizimana’s claim after finding material contradictions between his account of the accident and evidence presented by his own accident reconstruction expert.
According to the SAFLII judgment, Bizimana was riding from Fisantekraal towards Durbanville on the night of 4 April 2021 when his motorcycle collided with a vehicle driven by Adian August.
Bizimana told the court that the road was dark and unlit and that August appeared to lose control while negotiating a bend. He alleged that the vehicle crossed into his lane and struck his right leg.
He said he tried to avoid the collision by moving further to the left, but fell from his motorcycle.
Bizimana sustained a degloving injury to his right foot, a laceration to his right leg and an abrasion to his left hand.
He sought R4,758,033 in damages, claiming that his injuries affected his mobility and ability to work as a motorcycle delivery driver.
However, the evidence of his accident reconstruction expert, Patrick John Herron, differed from his version of events.
The judgment records that Herron placed the point of impact on a straight section of road, contradicting Bizimana’s account that the collision happened while the vehicles were negotiating a curve.
Under cross-examination, Herron also disputed that August had been swerving or that the collision occurred on a bend.
The judge found that these discrepancies concerned key aspects of the accident, including the vehicles’ positions, the point of impact and which driver had crossed into the other’s lane.
“The mere expression of the opinion that the insured driver was solely responsible does not resolve the evidential difficulty,” Yake said.
The court also noted that the RAF had not called any witnesses during the proceedings. However, the judge said this did not automatically mean Bizimana was entitled to succeed.
“The plaintiff’s case must stand or fall on the strength of the evidence he presented,” the judgment states.
Yake found that Bizimana had failed to prove, on a balance of probabilities, that August’s negligence caused the collision.
The court dismissed the claim without having to determine the RAF’s alternative argument that Bizimana had contributed to the accident through his own negligence.
Bizimana was ordered to pay the RAF’s party-and-party legal costs for the liability proceedings, including the trial and counsel’s fees on Scale B.
According to TimesLIVE, the claim included compensation for pain and suffering, emotional shock, mobility and working-capacity impairment, as well as loss of earning capacity.
Follow African Insider on Facebook, X and Instagram
Picture: Unsplash
For more African news, visit Africaninsider.com
Compiled by Glaan Sibuyi


