Cape Town – Electricity customers in five South African municipalities could be entitled to refunds after the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (NERSA) admitted that tariffs approved for the 2025/26 financial year were based on incorrect calculations.
The affected municipalities are Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Nelson Mandela Bay, Emfuleni and Madibeng. NERSA also conceded that it failed to properly verify figures submitted by the municipalities before approving the tariffs.
The issue emerged during proceedings in the Pretoria High Court on 9 November, following legal action by major electricity users including Coega Steels, Mpact, Autocast SA and the Casting, Forging and Machining Cluster of South Africa. According to MyBroadband, businesses in Nelson Mandela Bay were paying electricity tariffs 76% higher than the municipality’s cost of supplying the power.
The Citizen reported that NERSA described its approvals as “indefensible” after errors in the figures underpinning the municipal tariff applications were exposed. The court is now considering how consumers who overpaid should be compensated.
Financial challenge
NERSA has argued that any corrections should benefit all customers in the affected municipalities, rather than only the companies that brought the court applications. It has also asked for the tariff corrections to be phased in over several years to limit the financial impact on municipalities.
The scale of the potential refunds could create a significant administrative and financial challenge for municipalities. AfriForum’s head of local government affairs, Morné Mostert, warned that processing refunds could be particularly difficult for prepaid customers.
“You can imagine what would happen if a municipality that already struggles to meet basic requirements in regulations and law must now go back in their financial systems and credit people,” Mostert said, according to MyBroadband.
BusinessTech quoted Pietermaritzburg and Midlands Chamber of Business CEO Melanie Veness as saying affected customers should receive credits for the excess amounts they paid.
“They need to be compensated. They need to enjoy the credits for the overpayments that they’ve made,” Veness said.
The case also highlights broader concerns about municipal electricity tariff calculations. Earlier legal challenges established that municipalities are required to provide proper cost-of-supply studies to justify their tariffs. MyBroadband reported that more than 100 municipalities had previously faced scrutiny over compliance with these requirements.
The court is expected to determine how the unlawful tariffs should be corrected and how customers who were overcharged should receive relief. The Citizen reported that Judge RG Tolmay has raised the possibility of appointing an independent expert to establish the extent of the overcharging and help ensure affected customers can be credited.
Follow African Insider on Facebook, X and Instagram
Picture: Pixabay
For more African news, visit Africaninsider.com
Compiled by Betha Madhomu


