Cape Town – Democratic Alliance (DA) leader Geordin Hill-Lewis is reportedly considering swapping political positions with Helen Zille, offering to move from Cape Town to Johannesburg to become mayor in a move that could break the deadlock in coalition negotiations with ActionSA.
According to an exclusive report by the Sunday Times, the proposal would see Hill-Lewis leave his position as Cape Town mayor to contest the Johannesburg mayoralty, while Zille returns to the Western Cape to take over the position he vacates.
Multiple sources within the DA and ActionSA reportedly confirmed that the proposal had been presented to ActionSA leaders as the parties seek an agreement to govern Johannesburg and other Gauteng municipalities.
The reported proposal comes amid growing tensions between the DA and ActionSA, whose leader, Herman Mashaba, has made Zille’s removal as the DA’s Johannesburg mayoral candidate a major obstacle to coalition negotiations.
A senior DA insider told the Sunday Times that the arrangement was being considered as a way to break the impasse.
A hard pill to swallow
“This is an idea that’s being floated by a number of people as a way to try to resolve this issue,” the source said, adding that Hill-Lewis’s move to Johannesburg could help secure a DA-ActionSA agreement and prevent the ANC from taking control of Gauteng’s major metropolitan municipalities.
Hill-Lewis, however, did not confirm or deny the reported proposal, telling the publication: “We don’t negotiate in the media. All options are on the table. That’s the nature of such a wide-ranging and consequential negotiation for our country.”
Another senior DA source acknowledged that the proposal could be politically difficult, particularly for the party in Gauteng, but said it was not being ruled out.
“It would be a hard pill to swallow for us in Gauteng, but we are not going to the negotiation table with anything off the table,” the source said.
Zille, meanwhile, appeared to dismiss the possibility of returning to Cape Town, telling the Daily Maverick that she had heard the speculation but was not taking it seriously.
Logistical and procedural hurdles
“It is a rumour I have also heard on the rumour mill. But I am not taking it seriously,” she said.
The Daily Maverick also reported that the proposed arrangement could face logistical and procedural hurdles, although Stellenbosch University political and public leadership expert Dr Len Mortimer said a swap was legally possible, subject to the necessary municipal and party-list processes.
ActionSA has maintained that its objections are directed at Zille and former Tshwane mayor Cilliers Brink rather than the DA as a party.
ActionSA chairperson Michael Beaumont told the Sunday Times that his party remained open to negotiations if the DA addressed its concerns.
“We have consistently repeated that should the DA help to address this problem, we would be amenable for discussions to engage around coalition discussions in both of those municipalities, as well as others,” Beaumont said.
Major metros
The standoff follows the 2026 local government elections, in which the DA emerged as the largest party in Johannesburg with 34.8% of the vote, followed by the ANC with 20.3% and ActionSA with 16.3%, according to IOL.
In an earlier proposal reported by TimesLIVE, Mashaba had offered to withdraw from the Johannesburg mayoral race if Zille also stepped aside, allowing the DA to nominate another candidate while ActionSA took the deputy mayor position.
The latest proposal involving Hill-Lewis signals the extent of the political manoeuvring as parties attempt to secure control of Gauteng’s major metros, including Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni.
However, the reported mayoral swap remains unconfirmed, with the outcome of coalition negotiations likely to determine whether the arrangement becomes a realistic option.
Follow African Insider on Facebook, X and Instagram
Picture: Screengrab
For more African news, visit Africaninsider.com
Compiled by Betha Madhomu


