Dublin – Springbok assistant coach Mzwandile Stick has accused rugby authorities of applying double standards in disciplinary decisions, questioning whether players from established rugby nations receive more favourable treatment than those from smaller countries.
In comments reported by IOL, Stick made the remarks on Friday ahead of South Africa’s Nations Championship encounter against Ireland, taking aim at the decision to clear Irish flyhalf Sam Prendergast following an alleged dangerous tackle on Fiji captain Peceli Yato.
Prendergast was cited for an alleged hip-drop tackle during Ireland’s 43-15 victory over Fiji on November 14, becoming the first Test player charged under World Rugby’s new regulations targeting the dangerous tackling technique.
However, an independent disciplinary committee dismissed the charge, allowing the Leinster flyhalf to face the Springboks.
According to Reuters, the incident occurred during the first half of the match and was not penalised by the match officials. Yato was subsequently replaced with an ankle injury.
Growing tensions
Stick questioned the outcome, suggesting a Fijian player accused of committing the same offence against an Irish opponent would have faced a suspension.
“If that was a Fijian player tackling an Irish player with that hip-drop, that player would be in Fiji now,” Stick said, as quoted by The Irish Times.
He added: “You know what they call a traditional drink in Fiji? Is it kava? If that was a Fijian player, he would be sitting in Fiji now doing some extra lessons on how to tackle. But it’s an Irish player, it’s free to play.”
The comments came amid growing tensions between South Africa and rugby authorities following head coach Rassie Erasmus’s six-match suspension for criticising match officials after the Springboks’ 21-19 defeat to France.
According to RTÉ Sport, Erasmus had questioned the officiating during the France encounter, claiming that 17 knee-drop tackles by French players had gone unpunished. He also predicted that Prendergast would escape suspension on a technicality.
Stick revisited the allegations, contrasting the treatment of Springbok lock Lood de Jager, who was penalised for a knee-drop tackle against Italy, with the alleged incidents involving France.
‘I’m not sure what’s right’
“I’m also confused. I’m not sure what’s right. I’m also not sure what’s wrong,” he said, according to The Irish Times.
He argued that the lack of consistency in interpreting the laws was creating uncertainty among players and coaches, who are expected to understand and enforce the regulations.
“When there are laws and new rules, people need to explain. The players look up to us as coaches. They also don’t know what’s right or wrong,” Stick said.
“We want to play the game clean and make sure players know how to tackle. But other parties aren’t coming to the party, and then we’re getting punished.”
The assistant coach also questioned the broader pattern of disciplinary decisions involving South African players, suggesting that suspensions had increasingly become a concern whenever the Springboks travelled to Ireland.
His remarks were also reported by SA Rugby Magazine, which highlighted his criticism of the Prendergast decision and his call for greater consistency in applying the laws.
🗣️ ‘No one is going to break us! I can tell you that for sure!’
Springbok coach Mzwandile Stick says Rassie Erasmus has been ‘hands on’ all week in training, but ‘his party’ will be at the hotel tomorrow evening. | 🇿🇦
Rugby on Off The Ball with @BankOfIreland | #NeverStopCompeting
— Off The Ball (@offtheball) November 20, 2026
Despite the controversy surrounding Erasmus’s suspension, Stick insisted that the Springboks remained united and committed to their preparations for the Ireland encounter.
“Rassie might not be in that coaching box, but he’s with us. We know one thing for sure, his energy will be there. And whatever we’re going to be doing tomorrow, we’ll do it for him,” he said, as reported by The Irish Times.
Stick also made a strong statement about his identity and pride in representing South Africa.
“I’m a proud South African. I come from Africa. I’m black from New Brighton. I’m a Xhosa. And I will never apologise to anyone about that,” he said.
He called for rugby authorities to ensure that disciplinary regulations are applied consistently across international rugby, regardless of the nationality or standing of the players involved.
“The new rules and laws need to apply to everyone,” Stick said.
Follow African Insider on Facebook, X and Instagram
Picture: X/@Springboks
For more African news, visit Africaninsider.com
Compiled by Bertha Madhomu


