Cape Town – South African restaurants can no longer automatically add a 10% service charge to customers’ bills under the guise of a discretionary tip, following a National Consumer Tribunal ruling against a Pretoria restaurant.
The ruling involved Tribeca Standard, which added a 10% service charge to customers’ bills automatically, despite describing it as discretionary on its menu, according to BusinessTech.
Customers had to approach management and complain about the quality of service to have the charge removed.
The Tribunal found that the practice contravened the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) and declared it prohibited conduct.
The case attracted attention after the restaurant confirmed during the investigation that approximately 200 service-charge transactions were processed daily, suggesting the practice was widespread rather than an isolated incident.
Earlier decision
In its report on the ruling, EWN quoted consumer journalist Wendy Knowler, who explained that the charge was effectively compulsory despite being labelled discretionary.
Knowler said: “If there’s a service fee you didn’t agree to, ask for it to be taken off, and you don’t have to complain about the service to do so.”
She also warned that diners could unknowingly pay the additional amount before adding another tip, advising customers to examine their bills carefully.
The restaurant reportedly cooperated with the Tribunal and confirmed that it had stopped automatically adding the charge and removed the relevant wording from its menu.
The ruling is consistent with an earlier decision involving Gauteng restaurant chain Braai Block, which was fined R1 million by the National Consumer Tribunal in December 2024 for adding undisclosed service charges to customers’ bills.
Tipping remains voluntary
According to The Citizen, the chain applied service fees across its 16 branches without including them in its advertised menu prices.
The Tribunal found that the practice violated Section 23(6)(a) of the CPA, which prohibits suppliers from requiring consumers to pay more than the displayed price of goods or services.
The National Consumer Commission welcomed the Braai Block ruling, saying it should serve as a deterrent to businesses that fail to disclose additional charges.
Meanwhile, EWN’s earlier reporting on compulsory restaurant service fees highlighted that tipping remains voluntary, with Restaurant Association of South Africa chief executive Wendy Alberts noting that customers have the right to reject an automatic service fee.
Consumers who encounter service charges they did not agree to can request their removal and, if a restaurant refuses, lodge a complaint with the National Consumer Commission.
Follow African Insider on Facebook, X and Instagram
Picture: Pixabay
For more African news, visit Africaninsider.com
Compiled by Betha Madhomu


