Cape Town – South Africa is considering changes to its internet and copyright laws that could compel internet service providers (ISPs) to block websites distributing pirated content, as Parliament steps up efforts to tackle growing digital piracy.
The proposal was discussed by Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Communications and Digital Technologies, which is examining ways to strengthen the country’s legal framework against illegal streaming and online content distribution.
According to MyBroadband, parliamentary content adviser Dr Jacob Medupe told the committee that existing legislation was inadequate to deal with modern forms of online piracy.
“It is quite a cancerous problem, digital piracy, and indeed the sector has been crying that they don’t have measures or safeguards that can protect that revenue leak that they’re experiencing,” Medupe said.
He estimated that about 23% of South Africans access pirate websites, generating approximately 168 million visits annually. He also cited industry estimates that digital piracy costs the global media industry more than $75 billion annually.
Clear provisions
Medupe said South Africa’s copyright framework was largely developed before the emergence of modern streaming platforms and lacked specific mechanisms to restrict access to websites distributing copyrighted material.
“The Act has no clear provision for court-ordered or regulator-directed website blocking, and therefore no procedural safeguards, oversight, or appeal route designed for blocking,” he said, referring to the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act (ECTA).
According to Sunday World, parliamentary researchers have similarly warned that existing laws, including the Copyright Act, ECTA and Cybercrimes Act, are not adequately equipped to address sophisticated online piracy networks.
The committee is considering a two-track approach that could involve interim regulatory measures and amendments to existing legislation.
One proposal is for the Department of Communications and Digital Technologies and the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA) to explore interim regulations providing ISPs with clearer guidance and legal protection when blocking websites involved in piracy.
Possible legislative amendments could also establish a formal legal basis for website blocking, introduce oversight mechanisms and allow dynamic blocking, which would make it easier to restrict access when pirate websites change their domain names or IP addresses.
Technical challenges
However, the proposal has raised concerns among internet service providers about the technical challenges and potential consequences of mandatory website blocking.
The Internet Service Providers’ Association of South Africa (ISPA) has argued that any blocking regime must be supported by a clear legal framework and judicial oversight to protect constitutional rights.
“As South Africa’s official Internet Industry Representative Body, ISPA accepts that there are some forms of illegal content that access providers may be obligated to block,” the association said.
“However, ISPA is adamant there needs to be a well-considered legal framework in place that respects the constitutional rights of South Africans and does not hamper the ability of ISPs to service consumers.”
In a position paper published by ISPA in July 2026, the association warned that website blocking could have unintended consequences, including restricting access to legitimate websites sharing the same IP addresses as targeted platforms.
More intrusive methods
It also cautioned that domain and IP address blocking could be bypassed using virtual private networks (VPNs), while more intrusive methods, such as inspecting internet traffic, could be costly and affect network performance.
The debate comes amid longstanding calls from broadcasters and copyright holders for stronger action against illegal streaming services.
In March 2024, the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development and MultiChoice signed a memorandum of understanding to strengthen cooperation in combating piracy.
The department said at the time that legislative gaps had left hosting providers and other intermediaries without sufficient incentives to assist legitimate industry players and law enforcement agencies in tackling online piracy.
The committee is also considering measures beyond website blocking, including shutting down illegal commercial operations, disrupting their financial networks, improving cooperation between enforcement agencies and promoting affordable legal content platforms.
The proposed changes could have significant implications for South Africa’s internet industry, broadcasters, content producers and consumers, although a final regulatory framework has yet to be established.
Follow African Insider on Facebook, X and Instagram
Picture: Pixabay
For more African news, visit Africaninsider.com
Compiled by Betha Madhomu


